Dual Passport/Citizenship Borderless Travel etc

I think we should explore the reasons why anyone would wish to have two passports.
I suppose ease of travel is the big one for most, but that comes with responsibilities.
Ukraine's dual citizens found that out to their cost.
The main advantages of having multiple nationalities:

Increased Travel Flexibility: This is especially beneficial if you are from countries ranked lower on the "Henley Passport Index". For frequent travellers holding Indonesian passports, this is the main advantage.

If you are holding a passport from a country with no or very little socials security benefit; if you were running out of money you could easily immigrate to another country and you get a lot of freebies, free healthcare, free eduction, free accommodation right from day one without the need to meet the residency requirement.

More opportunities with Less paperwork for Economic and Business activities: For instance, in Indonesia, there is the possibility to own freehold landed properties, to work in Indonesia, open a business with minimum restriction. Being able to work, open business in both countries with less paperwork and restriction is a significant benefit.

More Consular Protection and Assistance, Safety and Security: In case of emergencies such as political unrest, natural disasters, or other crises, having a second passport provides an exit strategy.

More Educational Opportunities: For example, an Indonesian citizen holding another passport, such as a UK passport would be eligible for student loans to study in higher education in the UK funded by the taxpayer. For this they also need to meet the residency requirement.

However, any rights come with responsibilities and therefore might become disadvantages/liabilities:

I have not studied this in detail, but in the example above of Ukraine's, Russian's dual nationalities, conscription for both countries might be mandated (?). What happen if they have both Russian and Ukrainian passport ? Family members, close relatives, might be fighting in the front line from the opposite site. Just as a reminder, Indonesian citizen are required to be ready for conscription if needed by the country. It is stated in the constitution.

The taxation might not be in your favour. For instance, this is one of the reasons frequently cited for why the co-founder of Facebook (now Meta), Eduardo Saverin decided to renounce his US nationality when he chose to reside in Singapore.

But in the vast majority of cases, the advantages will outweigh the disadvantages. I fully believe many people, if offered the opportunity, will choose to have multiple passports. It is similar to having multiple credit/debit cards and bank accounts in different countries.
 
Last edited:
I have 2 passports. But both British. And current. Active. Legal. Etc.
But that's because I'm special lol
 
Just as a reminder, Indonesian citizen are required to be ready for conscription if needed by the country. It is stated in the constitution.
This is the extract from the Indonesian Constitution UUD 45 with regard to Conscription:
"Article 30 Para (1) Every citizen shall be entitled and shall participate in the efforts towards the defense and security of the state."

There is no age limit here. So literally if needed and necessary they could legally call anyone at any age, gender to get involved in the conscription. Even those at retirement age, say 55+, could be trained and sent to the front lines to fight. But if it is done sensibly they will also consider the practicality.

In extreme cases, dual nationals might find themselves facing their own family members, siblings, children, or parents on the opposing side. But that possibility for this is certainly very distance.
 
Last edited:
In extreme cases, dual nationals might find themselves facing their own family members, siblings, children, or parents on the opposing side. But that possibility for this is certainly very distance.
Happened and is happening ... e.g. in WOII (Japanese citizens in USA) or in war Ukraine (Russian-Ukrainian citizens). Maybe later in the China - Taiwan war?
 
In extreme cases, dual nationals might find themselves facing their own family members, siblings, children, or parents on the opposing side. But that possibility for this is certainly very distance.
That's not because of a passport, but because of a state of mind, political choice, formatted (brainwashed) education etc....
Same as Reps / Dems in the US ..
 
That's not because of a passport, but because of a state of mind, political choice, formatted (brainwashed) education etc....
Same as Reps / Dems in the US ..
So,So, true! I learned long ago in America, to never bring up Politics, Religion, World Ideas, International Cuisine, Etc. Pretty much anything that a person with an open mind, might want to discuss! It's a great way to ruin a nice Family get together. There is always someone there that's ultra conservative, a religious fanatic, ultra Conspiracy theorist, ultra liberal. Basically a group of people that come together, for Celebrations, Holidays, Traditions, in the pretense of celebration, and secretly, can't wait to get the Hell out of there!
So you're very right, it would be a joy to many of them, to blow the others off the face of the Planet!
 
The main advantages of having multiple nationalities:

Increased Travel Flexibility: This is especially beneficial if you are from countries ranked lower on the "Henley Passport Index". For frequent travellers holding Indonesian passports, this is the main advantage.

If you are holding a passport from a country with no or very little socials security benefit; if you were running out of money you could easily immigrate to another country and you get a lot of freebies, free healthcare, free eduction, free accommodation right from day one without the need to meet the residency requirement.

More opportunities with Less paperwork for Economic and Business activities: For instance, in Indonesia, there is the possibility to own freehold landed properties, to work in Indonesia, open a business with minimum restriction. Being able to work, open business in both countries with less paperwork and restriction is a significant benefit.

More Consular Protection and Assistance, Safety and Security: In case of emergencies such as political unrest, natural disasters, or other crises, having a second passport provides an exit strategy.

More Educational Opportunities: For example, an Indonesian citizen holding another passport, such as a UK passport would be eligible for student loans to study in higher education in the UK funded by the taxpayer. For this they also need to meet the residency requirement.

However, any rights come with responsibilities and therefore might become disadvantages/liabilities:

I have not studied this in detail, but in the example above of Ukraine's, Russian's dual nationalities, conscription for both countries might be mandated (?). What happen if they have both Russian and Ukrainian passport ? Family members, close relatives, might be fighting in the front line from the opposite site. Just as a reminder, Indonesian citizen are required to be ready for conscription if needed by the country. It is stated in the constitution.

The taxation might not be in your favour. For instance, this is one of the reasons frequently cited for why the co-founder of Facebook (now Meta), Eduardo Saverin decided to renounce his US nationality when he chose to reside in Singapore.

But in the vast majority of cases, the advantages will outweigh the disadvantages. I fully believe many people, if offered the opportunity, will choose to have multiple passports. It is similar to having multiple credit/debit cards and bank accounts in different countries.
Thank you for a well written answer, but you missed an important point - Responsibilities.
I saw a thread somewhere about a US or UK citizen that had taken Ukrainian dual citizenship so could not leave that country as martial law rules stopped him.

We are in a semi-cold war at the moment and Indonesia is closer to China than it is the US. An EU/UK/US/Australian citizen could very easily find themselves in a very difficult position if the situation worsened significantly.
We have already seen the accusation/possibility of an outside country trying to get rid of Prabowo, and that could easily get worse.
Sticking to provable facts over conspiracy theories, one country has an extensive network of groups both within and without Indonesia that are in a position to create a strong narrative in an attempt to stir trouble in the hope of removing Prabowo.

If you read the local English language press, one outlet is producing a lot of anti-government stories that, after minimal checking, are lies at best. That particular outlet is connected to one candidate, and that candidate is linked to numerous groups funded by a foreign country.
Only three news outlets publish those stories whilst the rest ignore them or print the truthful version.

If it gets worse, dual citizens are going to have to make decisions very quickly.
 
What the Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Investment, Luhut, said about dual citizenship might have been misunderstood. Keep in mind his statement coincided with Microsoft's announcement of a $1.7 billion investment in artificial intelligence and cloud services in Indonesia. It seems that the concept they are promoting is not dual citizenship as generally understood, but something more akin to the Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) model. But this idea is not new in Indonesia and have surfaced multiple times in the past with no realisation.

To implement dual citizenship, Indonesia's citizenship law, UU No. 12/2006, would need to be amended. Any changes to the law must be presented to and approved by parliament; the president or minister cannot simply issue a regulation or instructions that contradict the existing law.

This OCI plan has been publicly confirmed by the Minister for Law and Human Rights during the Discussion on dual citizenship with the Indonesian diaspora on 30 May 2024.

 
Last edited:

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,582
Messages
110,640
Members
3,871
Latest member
Nadiarrr
Back
Top Bottom