Vapes are now haram

As far as I know cigarettes have always been haram in Islam itself but not sure the MUI ever declared it. Like many things in Islam, there may be multiple opinions across the board. Not sure that the MUI decision really means a lot to most Muslims.
 
How can cigarettes be haram in Indonesia if two thirds of adult males smoke? Are you saying haram\halal rules are meaningless?
Just to be clear I am saying that just like any religion there are different levels of dedication by the members. Add into that different opinions of different bodies that may or may not agree with the local bodies and you have different people doing different things and thinking they are right. No different that Catholic and Protestants both being Christians and following different rules. Add in all the other subsets of Christians and you end with things that don't appear to be the same religion all claiming to be the only one that is right.
 
Being a poof is haram now watch trans7 lol everyone mincing around on those shows. All straight? Lol
And so many hijabis in bars actually drinking openly not even wine in a teapot but knocking back cocktails and making an arse of themselves later.

And plenty of muslims eat pork. Jungle tuna

Sex before marriage. Etc etc. Luckily all my gfs are already married lol
 
To be haram or not to be haram? The question hardly matters when you look at the huge amounts of money taken by industry and, according to AI,


    • PT HM Sampoerna Tbk (majority-owned by Philip Morris International): Long ranking as one of the largest and most profitable tobacco operations in the country. [1]
    • PT Djarum (owned by the Hartono brothers, Budi and Michael Hartono): Consistently ranked as the richest family in Indonesia, deriving a massive portion of their multi-billion-dollar empire and investments from the Djarum cigarette business.
    • PT Gudang Garam Tbk (founded by the Wonowidjojo family): Another colossal player pulling in billions of dollars in annual revenue. [1]
    I daresay they have enough lobbying power to ensure that the issue of haram is not pushed by government.
 
To be haram or not to be haram? The question hardly matters when you look at the huge amounts of money taken by industry and, according to AI,


    • PT HM Sampoerna Tbk (majority-owned by Philip Morris International): Long ranking as one of the largest and most profitable tobacco operations in the country. [1]
    • PT Djarum (owned by the Hartono brothers, Budi and Michael Hartono): Consistently ranked as the richest family in Indonesia, deriving a massive portion of their multi-billion-dollar empire and investments from the Djarum cigarette business.
    • PT Gudang Garam Tbk (founded by the Wonowidjojo family): Another colossal player pulling in billions of dollars in annual revenue. [1]
    I daresay they have enough lobbying power to ensure that the issue of haram is not pushed by government.
That's one of the reasons that local decisions may not be taken as seriously. Either way just like any religion there are some that claim to be adherents but don't really follow the rules. And then some may hide it better than others.
 
Since Islam seems to be pick and mix, why bother annoying the entire community to interrupt the sleep of elderly people and babies at 4am with 115db foghorns. Why not just say 'get up if you want to and put an alarm clock on if you feel strongly about it'. The practice of using mosque loudspeakers is definitely not halal, because it purposely and knowingly damages the health of vulnerable people, so I hope those speakers do not get a halal certificate.
No other religion has such a plethora of rules which cause such harm. Surely it must be time to reconsider the way it is designed.
Were you to utter these sentiments in some places you might find yourself charged with blasphemy.
 
Seems like almost any topic on this forum about Islam turns into bashing. The same complaints over and over again like something is going to change. You are living in the largest Muslim majority country in the world. Did no one suspect these things before choosing to live here?
 
Good way to close down a discussion (y)
Not meaning to close down a discussion but one has to be mindful of addressing these issues and possible consequences. While there are many Muslims who believe that theirs is a religion of peace and tolerance, within the ranks are a lot of overly sensitive Muslims who see any questioning of the religion as insulting. Ahok was an example and some foreigners thinking they could go to a local mosque and ask them to turn down the sound have paid a price.

Gibbon's classic "The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire has him noting the circumstances in which Muhammad and his followers turned to armed raiding after their migration from Mecca to Medina in 622 AD.

Gibbon writes, "The Arab continued to unite the professions of a merchant and a robber; and his petty excursions for the defence or the attack of a caravan insensibly prepared his troops for the conquest of Arabia." Gibbons then describes how the spoils were divided, with one-fifth reserved for Muhammad and the remainder distributed among his followers."

Gibbon also makes the broader observation that: "The caravans that traverse the desert are ransomed or pillaged"

Now, I wonder how raising these references would go down in a public debate in Indonesia.
 
Not meaning to close down a discussion but one has to be mindful of addressing these issues and possible consequences. While there are many Muslims who believe that theirs is a religion of peace and tolerance, within the ranks are a lot of overly sensitive Muslims who see any questioning of the religion as insulting. Ahok was an example and some foreigners thinking they could go to a local mosque and ask them to turn down the sound have paid a price.

Gibbon's classic "The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire has him noting the circumstances in which Muhammad and his followers turned to armed raiding after their migration from Mecca to Medina in 622 AD.

Gibbon writes, "The Arab continued to unite the professions of a merchant and a robber; and his petty excursions for the defence or the attack of a caravan insensibly prepared his troops for the conquest of Arabia." Gibbons then describes how the spoils were divided, with one-fifth reserved for Muhammad and the remainder distributed among his followers."

Gibbon also makes the broader observation that: "The caravans that traverse the desert are ransomed or pillaged"

Now, I wonder how raising these references would go down in a public debate in Indonesia.
AI says that 1/5 didn't go to the Prophet directly, it went to a special division of people. Again we bash using things that just aren't true. You can try to spread BS like this but you will likely be called out.

How the One-Fifth (Khums) was Allocated
The 1/5th share was not kept by Muhammad as personal private wealth for himself alone; rather, the Quran assigned it into six categories:
    • Allah and His Messenger (used for the needs of the Islamic community, state administration, and the Prophet's household/mission)
    • Close relatives (specifically Banu Hashim and Banu Al-Muttalib)
    • Orphans
    • The poor (needy)
    • Wayfarers (travelers in need)
 
I do not see how it is "bashing" to quote from long established histories. Written during the 18th century it reflected the anti-clerical, ironic and sceptical view of religious fanaticism. I am not suggesting that this is some kind of critical proof but making the point how difficult it is to have a critical debate about Islam.

Visual satire of Christian figures (such as Jesus or the Pope) is commonplace in Western media and rarely provokes widespread geopolitical crises. In contrast, Islamic tradition strictly prohibits visual depictions of Muhammad, making cartoons or satirical imagery a major flashpoint over free speech versus religious respect.
 
I do not see how it is "bashing" to quote from long established histories. Written during the 18th century it reflected the anti-clerical, ironic and sceptical view of religious fanaticism. I am not suggesting that this is some kind of critical proof but making the point how difficult it is to have a critical debate about Islam.

Visual satire of Christian figures (such as Jesus or the Pope) is commonplace in Western media and rarely provokes widespread geopolitical crises. In contrast, Islamic tradition strictly prohibits visual depictions of Muhammad, making cartoons or satirical imagery a major flashpoint over free speech versus religious respect.
You don't think that spreading demonstrably false information about Mohamed's greed is not bashing? Especially given the way Islam has been treated by Western people through the years. A one minute check showed that it was misinformation. A lot of things said about Islam are misinformation but no one bothers to fact check what is spread. At the end of your false statement you can blame the extremists for stifling free speech. Not bashing though.
 
Gibbon's classic "The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire has him noting the circumstances in which Muhammad and his followers turned to armed raiding after their migration from Mecca to Medina in 622 AD.

Gibbon writes, "The Arab continued to unite the professions of a merchant and a robber; and his petty excursions for the defence or the attack of a caravan insensibly prepared his troops for the conquest of Arabia." Gibbons then describes how the spoils were divided, with one-fifth reserved for Muhammad and the remainder distributed among his followers."

Gibbon also makes the broader observation that: "The caravans that traverse the desert are ransomed or pillaged"

A little bit of context... the caravans that were raided belonged exclusively to the Quraysh, the ruling merchant aristocracy of Mecca who had persecuted the early Muslims, forced them into exile, and seized and stole the property and belongings they left behind. In many cases these stolen assets were sold to fund the very trade caravans now passing near Medina. Caravans belonging to neutral tribes, Jewish communities, or non-Meccan merchants passing through the region were not targeted.

Now, I wonder how raising these references would go down in a public debate in Indonesia.
I'm sure that many won't shy away from an honest and respectful debate.
 
So what then should we make of the response to Ayaan Hirsi Magan who co-wrote the short film Submission (2004) with Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh, which criticized the treatment of women under Islamic law and led to van Gogh's murder by an extremist and ongoing death threats against her.
 
So what then should we make of the response to Ayaan Hirsi Magan who co-wrote the short film Submission (2004) with Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh, which criticized the treatment of women under Islamic law and led to van Gogh's murder by an extremist and ongoing death threats against her.
I think you answered your own question when you said extremist. There are extremists in every religion. Read what some of the Jews are saying about Palestinians.
"Yes, an Israeli lawyer and West Bank settler named Yehuda Shimon stated in a BBC interview that one Jewish life is worth 10 million Palestinians, while justifying retaliatory violence against Palestinian villages.[1, 2]" He has a lot of people that agree. Branch Davidian's clamied Christianity. There are even extreme Buddhists. No religion is safe from them but you can't hold a whole religion responsible for the acts of a few extremists.
 
We can agree about extremists but I don't recall any recent blasphemy charges regarding people complaining about church bells or death sentence Fatwas for people making offensive remarks about Christianity as happened with Salman Rushdie, Ayaan Hirsi Magan or American cartoonist Molly Norris, who proposed "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" in 2010.

I can appreciate the need to be sensitive to different religious beliefs. And with that I will leave this topic.
 

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

No members online now.

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,768
Messages
114,146
Members
4,058
Latest member
bravo
Back
Top Bottom