Global Citizenship Indonesia (GCI) and ways to regain Indonesian citizenship.

[grandee7]

Definitely gonna have a problem then.

Assume you entered US on that passport. You can't exit on ID passport.

And to enter ID on US you need a visa
LIke I said the best easiest safest way is enter ID on the US pp just get a B1 online instantly for $35 before you fly. A day before do the customs forms.

When you check in at the US airport with your US passport they will ask to see you ID visa. B1. Which you have. With egate.

That's a PDF you can show them. It's VOA

30 seconds after you've gone through the eye scanner egate machine on arrival you get an email from immigration with a PDF which is your B1 valid for 30 days inc.

In 15 days go online and click to extend. Must upload pp. Pp pic. Dep ticket. Pay $35. Then next day or within 3 days go to the immigration office nearest your address it will tell you. There you have an interview. Photos. Signing. Then that B1 is extended 30 days. Another PDF by email.

No more extensions. Have to depart by the date on that visa. 30 days including that same day.

Finish.

So what are my options with regaining Indonesian citizenship?

 

[snpark]

You will have to give up your US passport and residency and green card and citizenship. Are you really willing to do that. There's a good chance you will never be allowed back in the US. You will lose everything. All your social security etc. And it's going to be a long complicated expensive process to regain your Indonesian passport.

And then you might never be able to return to US again with that President

Is being Indonesian or having the passport really worth it to you for you.

Remember you absolutely cannot have 2 passports. It's completely illegal.

 

[marcus]

... There's a good chance you will never be allowed back in the US.

... you might never be able to return to US again with that President

From Google AI : "Getting a U.S. visa as an Indonesian is moderately difficult but highly achievable with proper documentation. While over 90% of non-immigrant applicants (like B1/B2 tourism/business) qualify, success depends on demonstrating strong ties to Indonesia to ensure return. Key challenges include proving financial stability and navigating the mandatory in-person interview in Jakarta or Surabaya."

You will lose everything. All your social security etc.

From Google AI : "Retired Americans generally do not lose their Social Security benefits if they renounce their U.S. citizenship, provided they have earned at least 40 credits (roughly 10 years of work). Benefits are based on work history, not citizenship status. However, payments may be affected by the country of residence."

And it's going to be a long complicated expensive process to regain your Indonesian passport...

I don't agree .

Why don't you tell something about the process and cost ?

 

[snpark]

Yes yes yes
That's what it says
But the orange guy wakes up and things change.

The process is simple it says. But recently not so forgiving for approving

And I did say others will chime in.

I was hoping you because you know all these things.

Ok so you recommend he does it where. There or here

And renounce US first or apply for new ID first?

 

[marcus]

So what are my options with regaining Indonesian citizenship?

If you didn't notice , in post no.3 , Jstar already told you which Regulations you should follow . Go to
https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/4722/pp-no-2-tahun-2007 and
https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/211179/pp-no-21-tahun-2022 to get the 2 Regulations .

I suggest you to first read the 2007's Regulation , select the specific Articles applicable to you , and later check the 2022's Regulation to know if those Articles were revised or not (if a specific Article is not in 2022's Regulation it means that Article in 2007's Regulation is still in force , was not revised) . Take a final look at the 2022's Regulation to be sure no new Article (that affects you) was created .

From a quick look , besides the generics in the beginning , your specific rules start at BAB V , Bagian Ketiga , Article 43 .

 

[gemima]

From Google AI : "Getting a U.S. visa as an Indonesian is moderately difficult but highly achievable with proper documentation. While over 90% of non-immigrant applicants (like B1/B2 tourism/business) qualify, success depends on demonstrating strong ties to Indonesia to ensure return. Key challenges include proving financial stability and navigating the mandatory in-person interview in Jakarta or Surabaya."

From Google AI : "Retired Americans generally do not lose their Social Security benefits if they renounce their U.S. citizenship, provided they have earned at least 40 credits (roughly 10 years of work). Benefits are based on work history, not citizenship status. However, payments may be affected by the country of residence."

I don't agree .

Why don't you tell something about the process and cost ?

Getting a US visa is easy if you are rich, if you are young and have a job tying you to indonesia. When you get older/ retired/ ill then it won't be so straightforward and as Snpark says - who know what the orange tyrant will do at any stage.

 

[snpark]

Getting a US visa is easy if you are rich, if you are young and have a job tying you to indonesia. When you get older/ retired/ ill then it won't be so straightforward and as Snpark says - who know what the orange tyrant will do at any stage.

I know several people who have had 3rd 4th 5th visits visa rejected in the last 6-12 months despite multiple previous trips

 

[Hawk256]

Getting a US visa is easy if you are rich, if you are young and have a job tying you to indonesia. When you get older/ retired/ ill then it won't be so straightforward and as Snpark says - who know what the orange tyrant will do at any stage.

My wife was denied a visa to the US before we were married even though she owns a business in Indonesia. She has a sister in the US and that scares the hell out of immigration. So no, having a job or even owning a business doesn't make it easy to get a US visa.

 

[grandee7]

If you didn't notice , in post no.3 , Jstar already told you which Regulations you should follow . Go to
https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/4722/pp-no-2-tahun-2007 and
https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/211179/pp-no-21-tahun-2022 to get the 2 Regulations .

I suggest you to first read the 2007's Regulation , select the specific Articles applicable to you , and later check the 2022's Regulation to know if those Articles were revised or not (if a specific Article is not in 2022's Regulation it means that Article in 2007's Regulation is still in force , was not revised) . Take a final look at the 2022's Regulation to be sure no new Article (that affects you) was created .

From a quick look , besides the generics in the beginning , your specific rules start at BAB V , Bagian Ketiga , Article 43 .

Thank you for the reply. I noticed on this link, https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/211179/pp-no-21-tahun-2022, that it mentions in Government Regulation (PP) Number 21 of 2022, that I must apply for regaining Indonesian citizenship via the Minister.

Couldn't I simply travel to Indonesia, apply for regaining Indonesian citizenship? Then if I am rejected, wouldn't they tell me what I need to do to qualify for regaining Indonesian citizenship? I suppose even if my application was rejected, then it would be a step in the right direction given that they would tell me what I did wrong. I could possibly re-apply again after I found out what they require.

 

[grandee7]

There is a so called PP (Government Regulation) that tells you about the procedures for acquiring, losing, canceling, and regaining Indonesian citizenship. Look for PP number 21 of 2022, that one amends the PP number 2 of 2007.

But the issue here is more that the Indonesian government doesn’t seem aware you got a foreign citizenship. I wonder what would happen if you just applied for a new passport.

Yes, thank you. I suppose applying for Indonesian Citizenship with the intent to regain Indonesian citizenship would be interesting. Even a rejected citizenship application would yield some sort of feedback and let me know how to regain Indonesian citizenship or let me know if I still have Indonesian citizenship.

 

[grandee7]

You will have to give up your US passport and residency and green card and citizenship. Are you really willing to do that. There's a good chance you will never be allowed back in the US. You will lose everything. All your social security etc. And it's going to be a long complicated expensive process to regain your Indonesian passport.

And then you might never be able to return to US again with that President

Is being Indonesian or having the passport really worth it to you for you.

Remember you absolutely cannot have 2 passports. It's completely illegal.

Yes, I am absolutely willing to give up U.S citizenship. I want out of the U.S.A and want to get rid of U.S citizenship. Renouncing U.S citizenship is actually growing in interest by the year with Americans from all walks of life. I would never imagine returning to the U.S.A ever again, so I would not miss much. I understand social security is a grey area and I have heard that former U.S citizens can still collect social security payments.

From what I have been reading up on, various sources say regaining Indonesian citizenship is very difficult, and other sources say that if an Indonesian national never formally renounced citizenship, then they are still, technically Indonesian citizens. It almost sounds like they could regain it since they did not renounce it.

I actually prefer having only one passport such as my previous Indonesian passport. For example the U.S.A actually has very expensive fees and burdensome procedures to renounce U.S citizenship. Given that Indonesia only allows one citizenship, then by regaining my Indonesian citizenship, I would automatically lose my U.S citizenship. Americans automatically lose U.S citizenship when they gain citizenship in a country such as Indonesia that does not have dual citizenship. This works out great for me.

So to summarize, I want out of the U.S.A and I want to permanently divorce U.S citizenship. Regaining my Indonesian citizenship is the logical path to both accomplish this and to allow me to live permanently in Indonesia.

 

[snpark]

Ok fairy nuff.
If you were Indo before I can't see it being a problem. Are you or were you a Muslim also before

 

[pantaiema]

I actually prefer having only one passport such as my previous Indonesian passport. For example the U.S.A actually has very expensive fees and burdensome procedures to renounce U.S citizenship. Given that Indonesia only allows one citizenship, then by regaining my Indonesian citizenship, I would automatically lose my U.S citizenship. Americans automatically lose U.S citizenship when they gain citizenship in a country such as Indonesia that does not have dual citizenship. This works out great for me.

Based on a few cases, Ex-Indonesian are not required to officially renounce their Indonesian citizenship to lose the Indonesian Citizenship and/or to apply for GCI. They are relying on the law stating that you will lose your Indonesian once you hold a foreign passport. If you want to renounce your Indonesian citizenship first before reapplying to regain Indonesian citizenship, it will take moths if not years to do this officially as it will need to be approved by the Indonesian President.

I would automatically lose my U.S citizenship. Americans automatically lose U.S citizenship when they gain citizenship in a country such as Indonesia that does not have dual citizenship.

They are not so naive that some people might have thought.. They know that this statement is not true, so they will not use this premise. If you want to regain your Indonesian citizenship, they will ask you evidence such as statement letter from embassies, home office that you have started the process of renouncing your other citizenships and will only grant you an Indonesian Citizenship once you renounce your citizenship (get confirmation).

I think Indonesian Immigration might still miss the loophole for those who have multiple (not just dual) citizenships. A few people have three citizenships. If this is the case they just need to renounce one but they still have 1-2 they could use. Unless people voluntarily tell them, there is no way they could know how many other nationalities people still have.

There are already a few threads about getting an Indonesian citizenship in this forum. Search it.