Deportation and blacklisting

Deportation gets you a red stamp. Why should that not be case? Countries will ask you if you have even been deported. An honest answer should follow. I don't understand why you expect to be treated differently? Is there something I am missing?
Thank you for your reply. Sometimes a simple administrative things from once office can make them land in a difficult situation, not sure for that reason the applicant is fully responsible by taking a RED deportation stamp. I am not asking to treat this separately. But will the other nation immigration will consider this as a bad remark and reject the future visas, this is my concern.
 
I
Deportation gets you a red stamp. Why should that not be case? Countries will ask you if you have even been deported. An honest answer should follow. I don't understand why you expect to be treated differently? Is there something I am missing?
Deportation can get you a red or blue stamp, depending on the wrongdoing and funds.
 
I

Deportation can get you a red or blue stamp, depending on the wrongdoing and funds.
What determines the difference on which one you get? I have always heard about the red stamp. Didn't know there was another.
 
Thank you for your reply. Sometimes a simple administrative things from once office can make them land in a difficult situation, not sure for that reason the applicant is fully responsible by taking a RED deportation stamp. I am not asking to treat this separately. But will the other nation immigration will consider this as a bad remark and reject the future visas, this is my concern.
Simply "lose" your passport when back home and apply for a new one....
 
What determines the difference on which one you get? I have always heard about the red stamp. Didn't know there was another.
Blue stamp you are blacklisted 6 months, red one is more (5 years or more I think).
 
My office in Jakarta and I work too in Jakarta. My KITAS shows as System engineering Manager, Where as in the contract it show Senior Technical Manager.

I guess it's too late to do anything now as immigration has already issued deportation letter.

Your office had almost 2 months to settle the issue but failed to do so. The minor error should have been easily corrected without having to deport you. It's not as if you committed crime or overstayed your visa, I'm not sure if the errors are grounds for your deportation. Makes me suspect that your employer doesn't want you anymore, and they took this opportunity to "terminate" the contract. If only you knew what was coming, you could have quit the job and get an EPO instead of being deported.
 
I guess it's too late to do anything now as immigration has already issued deportation letter.

Your office had almost 2 months to settle the issue but failed to do so. The minor error should have been easily corrected without having to deport you. It's not as if you committed crime or overstayed your visa, I'm not sure if the errors are grounds for your deportation. Makes me suspect that your employer doesn't want you anymore, and they took this opportunity to "terminate" the contract. If only you knew what was coming, you could have quit the job and get an EPO instead of being deported.
It is a recent trend to chase foreigners for such minors discrepancies, and they are not so easilly corrected, unless by "other" means.

For these minor errors, the treatement is as if you did a crime.
 
Blue stamp you are blacklisted 6 months, red one is more (5 years or more I think).
What determines which one you get? Is there a list of infractions for each? Is it done case by case?
 
What determines which one you get? Is there a list of infractions for each? Is it done case by case?
Minor get you a blue one, but done on case by case basis. Wrong address/positions should be a blue one, or should not lead to deportation at all. Long overstays are usually red.
 
Minor get you a blue one, but done on case by case basis. Wrong address/positions should be a blue one, or should not lead to deportation at all. Long overstays are usually red.
Makes sense but we don't know all the details in the case. There was a 2 month period that it could have been resolved but wasn't. Telling Immigration you are in Bali when you are in Jakarta seems like it would deserve at least some attention. Maybe there is more to the story?
 
Makes sense but we don't know all the details in the case. There was a 2 month period that it could have been resolved but wasn't. Telling Immigration you are in Bali when you are in Jakarta seems like it would deserve at least some attention. Maybe there is more to the story?
All obligations on reporting and compliance are on the company - sponosor. If they did not want to assist in the matter (in official and unofficial means), the result could be the deportation.

The minor discrepancies (i.e. address in KITAS is office in Jakarta, living place nearby) is also not tolerated and used as a reason for deportation or "else".

Btw the new government fee for deportation removal in case of 60+days overstay is 90 million.
 
I guess it's too late to do anything now as immigration has already issued deportation letter.

Your office had almost 2 months to settle the issue but failed to do so. The minor error should have been easily corrected without having to deport you. It's not as if you committed crime or overstayed your visa, I'm not sure if the errors are grounds for your deportation. Makes me suspect that your employer doesn't want you anymore, and they took this opportunity to "terminate" the contract. If only you knew what was coming, you could have quit the job and get an EPO instead of being deported.
Agreed, my sponsor was slow to fulfil the penalty process, but they did transferred the funds to the Agent who was helping to resolve this issue ( this shows they were not in interest to discontinue my work agreement) after receiving the initial deportation letter. However, seems this issue was leaked and got escalated to the top Head of Immigration and that is the why the concerned Immigration refused for any penalty and agreed to process with deportation.
 
Leaks, kicked to the top head of immigration, funds transfers after the final ruling.

You have been played like a cheap fiddle.

The head of immigration has no interest in you unless you did something to embarras the ministry. Your agent transferring money after the deportation was finalized in letter form and knew that just took you for a ride. With that cheap fiddle. It's done. Finished. End of story.
 

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

No members online now.

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,284
Messages
104,856
Members
3,555
Latest member
Digitalsmarketers_
Back
Top Bottom