Vapes are now haram

No religion is safe from them but you can't hold a whole religion responsible for the acts of a few extremists.
But I know few religions who use kids or women as suicide bombers, who cut the throat of people including women and kids, who kill the redaction team of a newspaper because of a cartoon, who burn alive a fellow muslim and I could go on.

Now having lived in Cairo for a year in early 80's this didn't exist, Egyot being a multi religious society.
I have done 4 months in Saudi at the same period, and even if everything was peacefull you could feel that it wouldn't take much for them to turn against non believers.
I worked in France on construction site with a lot of North African workers. Everything was smooth, when we organized a bbq we always had two grills, one for any meat, one on which pork was not allowed. Plus the soft drinks of course.
The next generation started to be agitated, the following one was brainwashed...
Personally there is no way I would live in region of this believe. Hence Bali.

Many on here have done this choice and even went way further, up to them....
 
But I know few religions who use kids or women as suicide bombers, who cut the throat of people including women and kids, who kill the redaction team of a newspaper because of a cartoon, who burn alive a fellow muslim and I could go on.

Now having lived in Cairo for a year in early 80's this didn't exist, Egyot being a multi religious society.
I have done 4 months in Saudi at the same period, and even if everything was peacefull you could feel that it wouldn't take much for them to turn against non believers.
I worked in France on construction site with a lot of North African workers. Everything was smooth, when we organized a bbq we always had two grills, one for any meat, one on which pork was not allowed. Plus the soft drinks of course.
The next generation started to be agitated, the following one was brainwashed...
Personally there is no way I would live in region of this believe. Hence Bali.

Many on here have done this choice and even went way further, up to them....
Sounds like you are using all the talking points of people that dislike Islam using some very small amounts of extremist actions and a couple with no proof whatsoever. We usually agree pretty well but we are off on this one. Which religion literally drank the poison cool aid? The Branch Davidian's literally used their women and kids as shields then started killing them when it didn't work. I still question how much religion had to do with the Irish conflict but either way both sides killed innocent people in their exchanges. We can play this game all through history. You don't want to see what Christians or Jews do wrong or if you do, you don't want to admit it.
 
Last edited:
To be clear: committing suicide attacks is still suicide, which is haram in Islam. It does not matter that someone thinks they achieve something good by doing so.
 
Sounds like you are using all the talking points of people that dislike Islam using some very small amounts of extremist actions and a couple with no proof whatsoever. We usually agree pretty well but we are off on this one. Which religion literally drank the poison cool aid? The Branch Davidian's literally used their women and kids as shields then started killing them when it didn't work. I still question how much religion had to do with the Irish conflict but either way both sides killed innocent people in their exchanges. We can play this game all through history. You don't want to see what Christians or Jews do wrong or if you do, you don't want to admit it.
You're wrong about me.
And I have lived in and with people of different religions.
Myself, I am not a religious man.
It's not throwing some water on my forehead without my consent when I was 3 months old that was going to make me a "good Christian".
Of my 4 kids none has been orientated or received any religious education. They are all adults now and live very well without ANY religion.
But they know the basics of several religions as part of their general culture.
And yes I am aware of what was done during the Inquisition in Europe... but that was from 1200 to 1500.
We are in 2026 now.
 
To be clear: committing suicide attacks is still suicide, which is haram in Islam. It does not matter that someone thinks they achieve something good by doing so.
Does this mean that Al-Qaeda and associated Salafi-jihadist groups are not Muslim? As these sects explicitly framed the September 11 hijackers as shahid (martyrs) engaging in istishhad (martyrdom operations), using religious rhetoric to rebrand suicide as a noble sacrifice for a political and ideological cause
 
And yes I am aware of what was done during the Inquisition in Europe... but that was from 1200 to 1500.
We are in 2026 now.
Everything I mentioned has been in the last 50 years but it really doesn't matter. You will find hateful things done in the name of religion in any time frame. It's nothing personal and I was probably stating things that you personally didn't involve yourself in. My apologies.
 
Last edited:
Does this mean that Al-Qaeda and associated Salafi-jihadist groups are not Muslim? As these sects explicitly framed the September 11 hijackers as shahid (martyrs) engaging in istishhad (martyrdom operations), using religious rhetoric to rebrand suicide as a noble sacrifice for a political and ideological cause
I will let him answer for himself but while they may call them selves Muslims, they are not following the rules and will be punished in the afterlife instead of being rewarded like they think

Surah Al-Ma'idah (Chapter 5, Verse 32) of the Quran:

“...whoever takes a life—unless as a punishment for murder or mischief in the land—it will be as if they killed all of humanity; and whoever saves a life, it will be as if they saved all of humanity.”
.
In the same vein was Jim Jones being a good socialist Christian when he passed out the Kool Aid including to 300-400 Children? Were the Branch Davidians being good Christians when they used their own children as shields against the ATF and then murdered them when it didn't work? Are the Israelis being good Jews by committing Genocide in Palestine?

What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, we could literally do it until both of us are sick of hearing it. Not sure why you are stuck on one group of people when it's obvious they were wrong to everyone. No one needs reminding. There are twisted people that get involved with religon. You can't blame the whole religion for them.
 
I will let him answer for himself but while they may call them selves Muslims, they are not following the rules and will be punished in the afterlife instead of being rewarded like they think

Surah Al-Ma'idah (Chapter 5, Verse 32) of the Quran:


.
In the same vein was Jim Jones being a good socialist Christian when he passed out the Kool Aid including to 300-400 Children? Were the Branch Davidians being good Christians when they used their own children as shields against the ATF and then murdered them when it didn't work? Are the Israelis being good Jews by committing Genocide in Palestine?

What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, we could literally do it until both of us are sick of hearing it. Not sure why you are stuck on one group of people when it's obvious they were wrong to everyone. No one needs reminding. There are twisted people that get involved with religon. You can't blame the whole religion for them.
"What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, ...."

I thought we were having a discussion rather than an argument. Can we not present differing points of view without acrimony?
 
"What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, ...."

I thought we were having a discussion rather than an argument. Can we not present differing points of view without acrimony?
When did it become an argument? Seems like a well-stated retort to me and shows a pattern of people doing evil things even though they claimed a religion was their motivation. Seems like a case of dishing it out but not being able to take it to me.
 
This goes back to the British empire, the Balfour declaration and the Sykes-Picot partitioning of the region.
And the Rotschilds bankers...
Does that relieve the Jews of their actions now? Killing, starving and cutting off of medicine seems like something you could quit anytime you wanted to.
 
When did it become an argument? Seems like a well-stated retort to me and shows a pattern of people doing evil things even though they claimed a religion was their motivation. Seems like a case of dishing it out but not being able to take it to me.
Well it is your own words in your post 27 that you suggest we are having an argument. "What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, we could literally do it until both of us are sick.."

As for Israel I don't think any forum members would justify the measures taken by Zionist extremist which has seen so many death of Palestinians, the destruction of Gaza and the continuing outrageous attacks by settlers spilling over from the West Bank. With Hamas and Hezbollah believing Israel should be wiped off the map and Zionist extremists wanting to return to greater Israel of 2000 years ago it is difficult to seen any resolution.
 
Well it is your own words in your post 27 that you suggest we are having an argument. "What a waste of time to make these kinds of arguments, we could literally do it until both of us are sick.."
You are correct bad choice of words on my part.
 
Does that relieve the Jews of their actions now? Killing, starving and cutting off of medicine seems like something you could quit anytime you wanted to.
Now ir's worse than before..
Before a majority of muslims lived in harmony with a minority of Jews (1900).
The Balfour agreement + Rotschild Bank favored and facilitated the return of Jews to Palestine. The balance changed. When the Brits pulled out (in their usual way "we're out of here, help yourselve) and the UN decided the sharing of Palestine between Muslims and Jews, Ben Gourion declared the state of Israel, UN said nothing.
From there on they felt they could do what they wanted...
And as no Western country put any sanctions on Israel (we even gave them the nuclear bomb) and supplies the weapons for the genocide.....
 
Does this mean that Al-Qaeda and associated Salafi-jihadist groups are not Muslim? As these sects explicitly framed the September 11 hijackers as shahid (martyrs) engaging in istishhad (martyrdom operations), using religious rhetoric to rebrand suicide as a noble sacrifice for a political and ideological cause
A muslim does not become an apostate (disbeliever) by commiting grave sins like suicide or killing innocent people.
The ideologies behind the groups you mentioned above that drive people to commit suicide, the killing of innocent people and other actions that contradict the teachings of islam are clearly misguided and dangerous. But to make takfir of these groups (calling them to be non-muslims) should only be done on an individual basis and cannot be done solely on someone's affiliation with them.
 

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,769
Messages
114,166
Members
4,059
Latest member
Ross
Back
Top Bottom