Autopsies, what goes on

Did Jessica do it?? It appears Mina wasn't poisoned with Cyanide, so not being a medical expert it's obvious she died of something, could it have been natural causes, brought on by stress of meeting with Jessica, young apparently fit people sadly do drop dead due stress or some unknown illness, if she was poisoned, with what, surely you bring a so called expert from Oz he could make a judgement and determine the cause, if you accuse someone of poisoning with cyanide, and they weren't then to me you haven't got a case, unless you can positively determine the cause of death
 
Did Jessica do it?? It appears Mina wasn't poisoned with Cyanide, so not being a medical expert it's obvious she died of something, could it have been natural causes, brought on by stress of meeting with Jessica, young apparently fit people sadly do drop dead due stress or some unknown illness, if she was poisoned, with what, surely you bring a so called expert from Oz he could make a judgement and determine the cause, if you accuse someone of poisoning with cyanide, and they weren't then to me you haven't got a case, unless you can positively determine the cause of death

I agree that there is a lack of compelling evidence in this case, but it does seem that she was poisoned in that coffee shop, becoming ill shortly after drinking an 'odd-tasting' Vietnamese coffee. And, with respect, there are very, very few people that keel over at that sort of age.

FWIW I think she did it, for motives unknown, but that she'll walk due to lack of evidence. Still I have absolutely zero legal knowledge or experience :gossip:
 
The impression I have is that in the US, UK etc the justice one receives is almost directly proportional to your bank balance. There are exceptions but you only have to look at the profile of the prison populations to realize this is true.

In RI its probably the same, if not more so i.e. a woman can be jailed for stealing some wood and a 'connected' (rich) individual can walk for causing multiple deaths.

As for this case, I haven't watched any of the proceedings, but don't you think she did it ?

I don't know about the UK. In the USA the quality of the defense presented is, of course, improved by the financial position of the defendant, but to imply that all rich people get off and all poor people go to jail simply does not comport with reality. Many high profile defendants are convicted. The quality of the public defender system in the US is spotty, but many courts bend over backwards to assure that even those at the bottom of the economic pyramid are able to mount a credible defense. The reality is that most persons in US jails are there because they did the crime.
 
I don't know about the UK. In the USA the quality of the defense presented is, of course, improved by the financial position of the defendant, but to imply that all rich people get off and all poor people go to jail simply does not comport with reality. Many high profile defendants are convicted. The quality of the public defender system in the US is spotty, but many courts bend over backwards to assure that even those at the bottom of the economic pyramid are able to mount a credible defense. The reality is that most persons in US jails are there because they did the crime.
Another assurance in the US is the use of the jury system. It takes some prettysolid evidence for 13 people to come to an unanamus agreement. If in the end it is the failure of the system in some way there is also the appeal process that works faily well.
 
I don't know FP what 12 men good and true would make of this farce
 
The plot thickens, my wife tells me they are now interested in the husband, it appears he has quite a large life insurance on the poor girl, plus the fathers company is close to bankruptcy, also possibly poisoned before she arrived at the cafe,
 
Just very sad that such a young person with her whole life in front of her is now dead, regardless of the reasons.
 
FWIW I think she did it, for motives unknown, but that she'll walk due to lack of evidence. Still I have absolutely zero legal knowledge or experience :gossip:
As a matter of fact, when a trial "benefits" from a lot of media coverage, it very rarely ends up in an acquittal in an Indonesian district court. The notion of "walking [free] due to lack of evidence" is an odd one to hear for whoever is a bit used to the Indonesian Justice System.
Basically, either you have proofs that you are innocent and manage to get it accepted in court, or you manage to find a replacing culprit. If you don't avhieve any of these two, you are fucked, most of the time.
 
Basically, either you have proofs that you are innocent and manage to get it accepted in court, or you manage to find a replacing culprit. If you don't avhieve any of these two, you are fucked, most of the time.

That's about as straight and terse an overview as you'll get right there.
 
The OJ Simpson trail not one of Americas finest moments

One thing that often fails to be mentioned about OJ is the ensuing civil suit that was filed against him, which he ended up losing and being ordered to pay, I forget the amount, but millions of US dollars to the two victims' families. His story goes downhill after that.
 
One thing that often fails to be mentioned about OJ is the ensuing civil suit that was filed against him, which he ended up losing and being ordered to pay, I forget the amount, but millions of US dollars to the two victims' families. His story goes downhill after that.
Didn't he get caught with stolen property or something like that and sent to prison
 
One thing that often fails to be mentioned about OJ is the ensuing civil suit that was filed against him, which he ended up losing and being ordered to pay, I forget the amount, but millions of US dollars to the two victims' families. His story goes downhill after that.

Agreed, but if he hadn't been able to afford such a starry defense team, surely he would have done serious time for the double-murder.
 
The same farce has been on TV all day. The prosecution's police toxicologist, by his evidence of the amount of cyanide he presumed was in the cup, would have meant everybody in the restaurant would have died, or at least been sick.

Maybe a good ploy for the defense to ask if the judges would be witness to another re-enactment and get their families in the restaurant to act as other customers.... then bring in a cup of coffee laced with the amount of cyanide the toxicologist said he measured....... :painkiller:

They are prosecuting Jessica for murder.....and now don't even have any real evidence of how Mirna died. It's all supposition....and possible lies.
 
The same farce has been on TV all day. The prosecution's police toxicologist, by his evidence of the amount of cyanide he presumed was in the cup, would have meant everybody in the restaurant would have died, or at least been sick.

Maybe a good ploy for the defense to ask if the judges would be witness to another re-enactment and get their families in the restaurant to act as other customers.... then bring in a cup of coffee laced with the amount of cyanide the toxicologist said he measured....... :painkiller:

They are prosecuting Jessica for murder.....and now don't even have any real evidence of how Mirna died. It's all supposition....and possible lies.

Talking to a Prosecutor, I am told that if they can fit Jessica into the timeline picture, show that Mirna was poisoned, and have expert witnesses testify that Jessica's state of mind was such that she could have done it. That is all considered evidence and no smoking gun is needed. I was told that the Prosecution has a big win percentage of over 95 percent of cases here. I asked why and was told because the Prosecution is so complete with their case before going to trial. I just reply, "or, the system is so rigged you can't lose." They hate that. Show me any democratic nation where the prosecution wins that kind of percentage. Indonesia would see a big reduction of that percentage if they allowed trial by unanimous jury and break up the corrupt judge syndicate.
 
From Jakpost 15 Sep.....

"Budiawan, a toxicologist from the University of Indonesia (UI), has told the Central Jakarta District Court he is certain that any cyanide detected in the body of Wayan Mirna Salihin was naturally produced.
He was quoted as saying by tribunnews.com that the small amount of the hazardous substance in her stomach resulted from a chemical reaction that occurred prior to her death.
The expert witness, presented by defendant Jessica Kulama Wongso, told the panel of judges in Wednesday’s hearing that the 0.2 milligrams of cyanide that was taken from Mirna’s gastric fluid 70 minutes after she died was actually “nitrite compounds that had turned into cyanideâ€.
The testimony contradicted the statement by forensic expert Slamet Purnomo from Bhayangkara National Police Hospital in Kramat Jati, East Jakarta, that Wayan Mirna Salihin’s death was caused by cyanide poisoning.
Slamet said his testimony was based on a toxicologist’s report of a substance found in Mirna’s body.
"

Fastpitch said...'the system is so rigged'...and Atlantis suggested 'the defendant has to prove innocence'.....are valid statements as there aren't any checks and balances in favour of any defence.

With respect to OJ's case I read that the prosecutor (Clarke) said "Even if OJ had confessed I doubt if a jury in LA would convict him." The system in USA much favours a defendant because history has proved how easy it is to find someone guilty by presumption.
 

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

No members online now.

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,776
Messages
114,210
Members
4,069
Latest member
Mark59
Back
Top Bottom