Autopsies, what goes on

but I was more interested in the legal side regarding autopsies and post mortems
In cases where it is deemed necessary police may order an autopsy BUT must inform the family first if the victim can be identified AND the family can oppose it. If in the two days after being informed, no opposition has been filled, police may have the autopsy being conducted. In case of an opposition there are no way for the police to get it done.

This is regulated by art. 133 & 134 KUHAP.
 
In cases where it is deemed necessary police may order an autopsy BUT must inform the family first if the victim can be identified AND the family can oppose it. If in the two days after being informed, no opposition has been filled, police may have the autopsy being conducted. In case of an opposition there are no way for the police to get it done.

This is regulated by art. 133 & 134 KUHAP.

Thanks for all the feed back, what a strange system, I wonder how often it is abused. If you know what I mean
 
In cases where it is deemed necessary police may order an autopsy BUT must inform the family first if the victim can be identified AND the family can oppose it. If in the two days after being informed, no opposition has been filled, police may have the autopsy being conducted. In case of an opposition there are no way for the police to get it done.

This is regulated by art. 133 & 134 KUHAP.


Thanks for all the feed back, what a strange system, I wonder how often it is abused. If you know what I mean


Can it be opposed by family, even if the family is suspect?
 
Can it be opposed by family, even if the family is suspect?

I would have to wonder first, what is the echelon of the family? In Mirna's case, her parents made tge news as not wanting an autopsie and no mention of her husband's wishes. If parents can go over the spouse of their child in this case, what about things like medical decissions?
 
I didn't realize Mina was married, surprised the police haven't charged him with murder
 
I didn't realize Mina was married, surprised the police haven't charged him with murder

That was one of the first motives the prosecution presented. Jessica wanted Mirna's husband. Then, Jessica and Mirna were having an affair themselves. Both of which the judge tossed early on so the prosecution went on to another. They have no idea and keep tossing out guesses.
 
As I said before, you couldn't make this up
 
Fastpitch is correct...I recall they even tried to blame the husband for putting a hit on his wife. They are clutching for any reason and using this TV circus to get this girl convicted. Even tho' she probably did it there isn't any evidence, even circumstantial.
 
I have been watching this circus on tv ,with limited bahasa, and it seems to me the gang of judges have been trying their best to make the experts admit to a lethal dose of cyanide in her system.If it were true it would make their system look better. Poor prof. from UI. almost started crying from the intimidation.
 
Yes, it seems the expert witnesses for the prosecution who basically testified to the what if type of testimony were pretty much given a free ride but when it came time for the expert witnesses for the defense it opened up a bunch of name calling by the prosecution and a general belittling of them. Got so out of hand with all the yelling back and forth the judge actually suspended the hearing. Judge should have stepped in when the prosecution was attacking the witness, not wait until the defense attorneys started reacting to it. I think many of us have seen this happen previously.
 
Yes, it seems the expert witnesses for the prosecution who basically testified to the what if type of testimony were pretty much given a free ride but when it came time for the expert witnesses for the defense it opened up a bunch of name calling by the prosecution and a general belittling of them. Got so out of hand with all the yelling back and forth the judge actually suspended the hearing. Judge should have stepped in when the prosecution was attacking the witness, not wait until the defense attorneys started reacting to it. I think many of us have seen this happen previously.

Is there is no professionalism anywhere in this country ??
 
I'm still looking

Plenty of professionalism on display in Indonesia; one meets it on a daily basis, in offices, shopping, immigration, at work, etc..

Sometimes I feel that a number of the posters here should consider living somewhere else if life in RI is so impossible to cope with. I'm from the UK and have lived in a number of different locales, Europe, Asia, Middle East. Nowhere is perfect and some of the chicken little discussions here are laughable.
 
Plenty of professionalism on display in Indonesia; one meets it on a daily basis, in offices, shopping, immigration, at work, etc..

Sometimes I feel that a number of the posters here should consider living somewhere else if life in RI is so impossible to cope with. I'm from the UK and have lived in a number of different locales, Europe, Asia, Middle East. Nowhere is perfect and some of the chicken little discussions here are laughable.
Perhaps you might then provide balance to those discussions with either evidence "in favour" or comparisons with other locales.
 
Plenty of professionalism on display in Indonesia; one meets it on a daily basis, in offices, shopping, immigration, at work, etc..

Sometimes I feel that a number of the posters here should consider living somewhere else if life in RI is so impossible to cope with. I'm from the UK and have lived in a number of different locales, Europe, Asia, Middle East. Nowhere is perfect and some of the chicken little discussions here are laughable.

I will give Immigration a nod for getting better but according to many posters, it is only in some places, not over all. Shopping, offices I deal with, especially government, still suck. If i were still working, it wouldn't be here. Maybe read some post from those that do and dealing with their employers. Perhaps you are in a dream world someplace but I don't see the chicken little discussions since most are based on real peoples, real experiences.
 
Perhaps you might then provide balance to those discussions with either evidence "in favour" or comparisons with other locales.

How long have you got ? One example - I worked for 2 years down in Anyer: Construction then Operations as a Systems / Controls Engineer at one of the chemical plants along the road from Chandra Asri. Without exception the staff I worked with there, Operators, Supervisors, Engineers and Managers were as good, if not better, than any similar project I've worked on.

Immigration entry / exit and visa extensions over 20 years, never been asked an odd questions, tea money, bribe whatever. Not once (I've had a few long stares).

I've bought cars and motorbikes from new and they've all worked fine and been serviced well.

I've been in hospital a couple of times, no once, and also been to see a doctor twice. Minor stuff but their care and attention to detail was exemplary. And I'm talking about locally staffed and run clinics, not Gleneagles or similar.

Bought loads of stuff, small, medium and large items, and apart from a cheap watch I bought in Batam and 2 recent 'mishaps' in Bali, I've not been short-changed, ripped-off or otherwise conned. Without exception service has been fantastic and way above what one could expect in a number of western countries.

Even the few times I've come across officers of the law and or government officials - absolutely no problems at all to report.

Restaurants, bars, take-aways, hotels, banks, transportation, buying train tickets, boat tickets, air tickets, as good if not better service than any similar country I have lived or worked in.

I guess things don't go right all the time for everyone, but surely there has a to be a middle ground and as guests living in RI, we should at least talk about all the good stuff, rather than a 'isn't it shit here' diatribe from some of the regular posters.

On the 'old' forum there seemed to be a number of Yanks and Aussies that were in Jakarta / Indonesia on assignment and they seemed to treat living here as a form of extra-judicial punishment akin to hard labour in a salt mine.

And on a political note, sure the latest administration isn't perfect, but for my money Joko, Ahok and Risma are at least having a go at dismantling the hegemony that's ruled here since independence. I looked at the photos of the attendees at the latest ASEAN meet and with the exception of the new Burmese PM and Pak Jokowi, there was a long line of really dodgy leaders lined up like the gang from the film Usual Suspects: Thai's Army chief, Malaysia's PM with 100's of millions of Saudi money in his personal bank accounts, Vietnam, Kampuchea, Laos, Singapore's very well paid son of the founding father, Duterte (!!!) - what a bunch.
 
Immigration entry / exit and visa extensions over 20 years, never been asked an odd questions, tea money, bribe whatever. Not once (I've had a few long stares).

Count yourself damn lucky then.

Even the few times I've come across officers of the law and or government officials - absolutely no problems at all to report.

Aside from one awful experience—and it was a while ago—I've been lucky in this regard as well.

I looked at the photos of the attendees at the latest ASEAN meet and with the exception of the new Burmese PM and Pak Jokowi, there was a long line of really dodgy leaders lined up like the gang from the film Usual Suspects: Thai's Army chief, Malaysia's PM with 100's of millions of Saudi money in his personal bank accounts, Vietnam, Kampuchea, Laos, Singapore's very well paid son of the founding father, Duterte (!!!) - what a bunch.

That photo circulating of Najib, with is napkin still in hand, rising to get a quick photo op with Obama is a dreadful one.
 
Can it be opposed by family, even if the family is suspect?

Taken from:
PERATURAN PEMERINTAH REPUBLIK INDONESIA
NOMOR 18 TAHUN 1981
TENTANG
BEDAH MAYAT KLINIS DAN BEDAH MAYAT ANATOMIS SERTA TRANSPLANTASI ALAT ATAU JARINGAN TUBUH MANUSIA

BAB II

BEDAH MAYAT KLINIS



Pasal 2

Bedah mayat klinis hanya boleh dilakukan dalam keadaan sebagai berikut:

a. Dengan persetujuan tertulis penderita dan atau keluarganya yang terdekat setelah penderita meninggal dunia, apabila sebab kematiannya belum dapat ditentukan dengan pasti;

b. Tanpa persetujuan penderita atau keluarganya yang terdekat, apabila di duga penderita menderita penyakit yang dapat membahayakan orang atau masyarakat sekitarnya;

c. Tanpa persetujuan penderita atau keluarganya yang terdekat, apabila dalam jangka waktu 2 x 24 (dua kali dua puluh empat) jam tidak ada keluarga terdekat dari yang meninggal dunia datang ke rumah sakit.


According to that, no.
 
Taken from:
PERATURAN PEMERINTAH REPUBLIK INDONESIA
NOMOR 18 TAHUN 1981
TENTANG
BEDAH MAYAT KLINIS DAN BEDAH MAYAT ANATOMIS SERTA TRANSPLANTASI ALAT ATAU JARINGAN TUBUH MANUSIA

BAB II

BEDAH MAYAT KLINIS



Pasal 2

Bedah mayat klinis hanya boleh dilakukan dalam keadaan sebagai berikut:

a. Dengan persetujuan tertulis penderita dan atau keluarganya yang terdekat setelah penderita meninggal dunia, apabila sebab kematiannya belum dapat ditentukan dengan pasti;

b. Tanpa persetujuan penderita atau keluarganya yang terdekat, apabila di duga penderita menderita penyakit yang dapat membahayakan orang atau masyarakat sekitarnya;

c. Tanpa persetujuan penderita atau keluarganya yang terdekat, apabila dalam jangka waktu 2 x 24 (dua kali dua puluh empat) jam tidak ada keluarga terdekat dari yang meninggal dunia datang ke rumah sakit.


According to that, no.

Which part am I reading wrong?

P2 Autopsy is only allowed in the following circumstances:

a. With written permission of the deceased or the closest family members of the deceased, if the cause of death is as yet unconfirmed
b. Without permission if the deceased is suspected of having a disease which may endanger the public
c. Without permission if no member of the family appears at the hospital within 48 hours.

I don't see how the police can do it without permission, unless I am reading/translating wrong.
 

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

New posts Latest threads

Online Now

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
6,776
Messages
114,210
Members
4,069
Latest member
Mark59
Back
Top Bottom