Indonesia’s special needs students grapple with shortage of schools, teachers and facilities

They are very reluctant. I know students who had some type of learning difficulties, but the parents refused to test them. If they did apparently just giving them medication is the answer. Most teachers will just see them as a problem child.
 
In Holland raising a child up to the age of 18 costs 150,000 euros. In USA it's about 200.000 dollars. How about in Indonesia? I guess there are differences between social classes ...
 
They are very reluctant. I know students who had some type of learning difficulties, but the parents refused to test them. If they did apparently just giving them medication is the answer. Most teachers will just see them as a problem child.
ouch! Medicated students. o_O That makes me sad.

In October, 2021, the World Bank estimated that 30% of Indonesian learners with special needs were not being adequately served. Admittedly, this was during the "covid freakout", but 30% of learners is not a small number. The World Bank report is found here.

Here is a report from UNICEF which was released in Feb., 2023.

These issues are being discussed which is excellent. Now it's up to the universities to produce trained teachers for those exceptional students. :cool:(y)

Perhaps the Indonesian gov't could demand that a percentage of foreign investment be diverted into teacher training? The future of the country is being neglected by those learners being underserved, yes?
 
Last edited:
ouch! Medicated students. o_O That makes me sad.

In October, 2021, the World Bank estimated that 30% of Indonesian learners with special needs were not being adequately served. Admittedly, this was during the "covid freakout", but 30% of learners is not a small number. The World Bank report is found here.

Here is a report from UNICEF which was released in Feb., 2023.

These issues are being discussed which is excellent. Now it's up to the universities to produce trained teachers for those exceptional students. :cool:(y)

Perhaps the Indonesian gov't could demand that a percentage of foreign investment be diverted into teacher training? The future of the country is being neglected by those learners being underserved, yes?
Medicating children with ADHD is quite a common practice in many countries, though less likely in Indonesia perhaps due to the drugs used.
The meds used to treat ADHD tend to be amphetamines & whist Islam permits the use of such drugs in medical circumstances (under certain conditions) I can't imagine the vast majority of parents being ok with it.
However, these are just my own observations & opinions on the matter.

Yes, there is a huge gap in services for people who are neuro-divergent.
In schools these youngsters can often adapt and become very much included by the other children. In class, however (from a teaching perspective) there are targets set for class, there are so many minutes to deliver said targets to class, there are frequently 25 children to deal with in class.

When one or two children in that class act out or create distractions it can become very frustrating for the teacher, who is painfully aware that every extra minute spent with 1 child is taking away from the whole group's education.

The flip side of this is that the class as a whole is getting a different education by being 'exposed' to people who are neuro-divergent and how to adapt time and energy into working with them.
I think a short term and useful (but expensive) measure would be to train up classroom assistants who can help the students who are experiencing difficulties get extra support without it taking the teacher's attention away from the group as a whole.
Oftentimes a classmate takes on this role and whilst that is great for teaching empathy and responsibility it isn't fair on the classmate who is losing academic time from EVERY class.

N.B: I believe the term "Special needs" is now out dated.
[Edit]
In my daydream world I would love to set up a school that is adapted to deal with neuro-divergent students, yet is also open to all students, not just a select group.
Over the years I have learnt extensively about, and worked with children and young adults with ADHD and other conditions.
Support groups for parents are a good thing too.
 
Last edited:
In Holland raising a child up to the age of 18 costs 150,000 euros. In USA it's about 200.000 dollars. How about in Indonesia? I guess there are differences between social classes ...
Does this cost include the fees for primary and secondary education or only other childcare cost ? As I understand it the tuition fees for children in state schools in the Netherlands is free So are many other countries in Europe, regardless of their nationalities or the income of their parents.

For disadvantage children they get other supports, state benefit for bringing up their children. Some people especially benefit seekers may even want to have as many children as possible, because they will get benefit from the state for bringing up their children depending on the number of the children they have.

Having children is the well known loophole and thus become an attraction for abusing the asylum system for economic migrants in Europe and other developed countries. For failed asylum seekers they could have children as a mean to avoid being deported and get support/benefit from the states. Beside the usual UNHCR, activists; by having children they now have UNICEF, children charities, and populists politicians on their sides. Their only opponents are charities representing the taxpayers, looking into how the hard earned money from the taxpayers being spent effectively.

It does not apply to Indonesia as Indonesia is hardly ever (if any) pay any benefit. The childcare, education will be taken care by the parents, extended family or relatives. In Indonesia Children education in state schools should be free but in reality there are many other make up costs, which depending on the schools in questions could be considerably high for a disadvantage family.
 
Last edited:
Does this cost include the fees for primary and secondary education or only other childcare cost ? As I understand it the tuition fees for children in state schools in the Netherlands is free
Yes, not include school fees, because education (primairy and secondary) is free in Holland.

A child will cost parents around 15% of their net income. And 2 children around 25%. And 3 children around 40%.
 
Yes, not include school fees, because education (primairy and secondary) is free in Holland.

A child will cost parents around 15% of their net income. And 2 children around 25%. And 3 children around 40%.
Seems reasonable. After all with kids spending goes up on everything - housing, transportation, food, clothing.
 
Seems reasonable. After all with kids spending goes up on everything - housing, transportation, food, clothing.
Don't forget their hobbies: soccer, ballet, piano, hockey, tennis, golf, karate, dance ... 🤣
 

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Follow Us

Latest Expat Indo Articles

Latest Tweets by Expat Indo

Latest Activity

Online Now

Newest Members

Forum Statistics

Threads
5,859
Messages
94,813
Members
2,940
Latest member
movefla2
Back
Top Bottom